Melbourne City has been held to a 2-2 draw in the first leg of its Semi-Final tie with Central Coast, setting up a high-stakes rematch at home next weekend.
The Mariners opened the scoring through Brooke Nunne, who tapped in a parried Malena Mieres save in the 20th minute. Fortunately, City struck back comprehensively, first through a Leticia McKenna rocket from a dead ball, and then through a well-worked Bryleeh Henry goal in the 29th and 35th minutes respectively. However, the Mariners would continue to frustrate as Nunne again found the back of the net after rounding Mieres and looping her shot over the retreating defenders.
With so much now on the line, here’s what we learned from today’s tight affair:
The result is a difficult one to place in context
How should City fans feel about today’s result, then?
Whilst the team would have been heavily favoured to win, a draw away from home isn’t a bad result. Michael Matricciani had to name what was effectively a second-string front three of TJ Vlajnic, Shelby McMahon and Bryleeh Henry, whilst their counterparts Mariana Speckmaier, Holly McNamara and Lourdes Bosch were all injured or on the bench.
It was never mandatory for the job to be done in the first leg, but it was concerning that the Mariners kept pace with, and arguably outplayed, City throughout the 90 minutes.
This sets up a tantalising rematch next Saturday night.
A win next week is far from a foregone conclusion
We may be 28 games unbeaten in all competitions, but if we can’t defeat the Mariners next weekend, that record will count for half as much as the team will want it to.
In three attempts this year, City is yet to taste victory against Emily Husband’s outfit, playing out scorelines of 2-2, 0-0, and 2-2.
Today, it was no coincidence that the City girls were held to a stalemate. The Mariners came with a clear strategy of when to press the City backline and also found great success on the break. Both of the home side’s goals arrived via counterattacking situations, and the visiting back four were all at odds in either scenario.
Whilst a return to our home crowd and the possible inclusions of McNamara, Bosch, and Speckmaier to the starting XI should see City as favourites to win the second leg, progression to the Final will require something that we just haven’t been able to manage this campaign.

(Photo by Scott Gardiner/Getty Images)
McKenna proving again why City is so hard to beat
Whilst today’s performance hindered my confidence a little, I remain optimistic about City’s silveware prospects in both the A-League Women and the Asian Women’s Champions League, primarily due to the following factor: the variety of our goalscoring routes.
If an opposition team somehow manages to subdue McNamara, Bosch, Speckmaier and Henry, or if several of them are absent from the teamsheet like today, then City has other reliable goalscoring methods even when our performance hasn’t been to the usual standard. When City needed a break against the run of play this afternoon, McKenna unleashed one of the best free-kicks City fans have seen. Adding to her small handful of on-target dead-ball strikes this season alone, the midfielder has become a threatening set-piece taker and a reliable goalscoring weapon.
A fortnight ago, by comparison, the difference-maker was Taylor Otto and her headed goals from corners. Her strikes against Perth Glory to blow out the scoreline early were her fourth and fifth goals of her City career, and the tall central defender has proven herself an aerial threat at corners and set-pieces.
Between McKenna’s direct free-kicks and Otto’s aerial dominance, City has a couple of dangerous alternative routes to goal if its star attacking lineup is somehow contained.
















